|
Changing numbers of project affected families! |
|
|
CHANGING NUMBERS OF PAFs IN OFFICIAL DOCUMENTS: GAME OF NUMBERS IN SARDAR SAROVAR CONTINUES!
Changing Numbers at 110.64 metres Reference | Total PAFs (3 states) | Total PAFs in M.P. | No. of villages affected in M.P. | No. of PAFs resettled in M.P. | Balance for rehabilitation in M.P. | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 1. Status report as on 31.12.2005 (Ref: The Hindu 29.4.2006) | 27934 | 21693 | 143 | 8860** | 13233 | 2. Status of R&R as on 7.4.2006 (Annexure 2 in UOI’s application) | 13407 | 7166 | 104 | 7166** | 0 | 3. Agenda notes for 52nd meeting of R&R Sub-group of NCA, Feb 2002 | 18240 | 12681 | 135 | 12681 | Not given | 4. Minutes of 54th meeting of R&R Sub-group, Nov 2002 | 18240** | 12681 | 99 | - | - | 5. Half yearly status report of NCA on R&R, June 2003 | 13965 | 8406** | - | - | - | 6. Status of R&R (Summary Progress) as updated as of Feb 2006 from SSNNL website | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given |
** The minutes also report that the number will change after declaration of Awards which were remaining to be done for agricultural land in 8 villages and abadi in 21 villages Changing Numbers at 121.92 metres Reference | Total PAFs (3 states) | Total PAFs in M.P. | No. of villages affected in M.P. | No. of PAFs resettled in M.P. | Balance for rehabilitation in M.P. | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 1. Status report as on 31.12.2005 | 36921 | 28742 | 177 | 17197 | 11545 | 2. Status of R&R as on 7.4.2006 (Annexure 2 in UOI’s application) | 31500 | 23322 | 177 | 23322 | 0 | 3. Agenda notes for 52nd meeting of R&R Sub-group of NCA, Feb 2002 | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | 4. Minutes of 54th meeting of R&R Sub-group, Nov 2002 | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | 5. Half yearly status report of NCA on R&R, June 2003 | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | 6. Status of R&R (Summary Progress) as updated as of Feb 2006 from SSNNL website | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given |
Changing Numbers at 138.68 metres Reference | Total PAFs (3 states) | Total PAFs in M.P. | No. of villages affected in M.P. | No. of PAFs resettled in M.P. | Balance for rehabilitation in M.P. | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 1. Status report as on 31.12.2005 | 41440 | 33014 | 193 | 18505 | 1450 | 2. Status of R&R as on 7.4.2006 (Annexure 2 in UOI’s application) | 51447 | 43021 | 192 | 25004 | 18505 | 3. Agenda notes for 52nd meeting of R&R Sub-group of NCA, Feb 2002 | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | 4. Minutes of 54th meeting of R&R Sub-group, Nov 2002 | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | Not given | 5. Half yearly status report of NCA on R&R, June 2003 | 40963 | 33014** | - | - | - | 6. Status of R&R (Summary Progress) as updated as of Feb 2006 from SSNNL website | 51445 | 43021 | 240 | - | - |
Comments: - This indicates that the total number of PAFs at each height itself is changing even beyond the controversy over temporarily and permanently affected families, which was settled by the Supreme Court judgement of 2005.
When the total number of PAFs has increased by 10,000 families, then how can it be that the total number of families below 110 and 122 metres has been reduced, and the increase is only for families between 122 and 138 metres (full proposed dam height)??
|
Supreme Court 